My main beef with button down shirts? Not enough waist definition. This pattern style solves that problem with princess seams in the back and significant waist shaping at the side seams. Enough that I could easily (and very flatteringly) tuck it into pants without looking like a balloon on top.
The sleeve width is narrow and flattering, with no gathers at the wrist. I know that seems like an insignificant thing, but no extra fabric at the wrist makes for a much more attractive garment, in my opinion :)
I sewed a straight size 2, with some petite alterations. However, for my next version, I'll shorten the length above the waist, instead of where indicated on the pattern (below the waistline). I also shortened the sleeves by about 2" (which was perhaps 1/2" too much). I made the initial shortening before cutting out the fabric, but realized they needed additional reduction after sewing on the cuffs. Thankfully, I had enough fabric to recut the cuffs. This shortened the sleeve placket, but I think it looks just fine. In the next iteration, I may also reduce the hip flare a bit.
I really like this pattern. A lot. Some alterations for a personal fit and construction directions aside (next time, I'll construct the sleeve placket and collar differently than instructed), I am most definitely planning a second. And next time, I'm really going for it with Liberty cotton, if that gives you an indication of how highly I consider the quality of the pattern :) Several of the Glenjade colorways would be lovely.
Oh, speaking of fabric! This is Marc Jacobs shirting from Mood Fabrics (no longer available). It's light and pretty and the print is a little retro. I bought it to make an unspecified top a while ago, but since it was pretty inexpensive ($15 for 1.5 yards), I used for this wearable muslin here. Which reminds me--I made the top (with a second set of cuffs) in 1.5 yards, so that's good to know when I'm shelling out the big $/yard.
Here's how I wore it, with a bright orange sweater (from Anthro, a few years ago), cuffed-up jeans and maryjanes. And here is where I start to see the utility of collared, cuffed and button down shirts!
Resewlution 2015, January garment #2